Our Criteria

We believe everyone should be able to understand a whiskey review whether you’re new to whiskey or a seasoned drinker. To communicate how much we like a product, we use a rating scale of 1-10 with #1 being the lowest score and #10 being the highest score.

Our reviews use the following criteria to determine the product’s rating and our impressions and perspective.

  • Aroma
  • Flavor
  • Texture 
  • Finish
  • Unique or True to Style

We may also use the following criteria to suggest how to enjoy the product and better explain our perspective on the product.

  • Suggested glassware 
  • Atmosphere
  • Suggested for cocktails or neat sipper
  • Suggested food pairings?
  • Gifting suggestions?
  • Would I pour it for my peer?
  • Would I pour this for my bestie?
Credit: OurWhiskey Foundation, Jo Hanley